Maybe you discovered images of your unreleased app in an agency’s portfolio. Maybe your ex-vendor launched a product similar to your own. Either way, you’re wondering what happens if you break an NDA in a software project, or what to do when someone else breaks it.

In general, breaching an NDA will result in a civil claim for monetary damages, an injunction, or both. The specifics will depend on your NDA and the laws in your state. This is a general guide, not legal advice. It’s aimed at startup founders and managers who use external developers for their projects.

What Counts as an NDA Breach in Software Development

Laptop showing code on a busy desk

Photo by Christopher Gower on Unsplash

A breach of an NDA occurs when a party to the agreement discloses or uses information that is protected under the agreement's terms. In the context of software projects, this includes:

  • Releasing source code to the public (or to another project)
  • Exposing designs and mockups in a portfolio
  • Sharing product roadmaps and project ideas with a competitor (or using them to build a similar product)
  • Handling user data without proper care (e.g., exporting or retaining it, or passing it on to an unapproved third party)
  • Sharing the list of clients or vendors with a third party

When it comes to code, there are gray areas. Developers reuse their skills and tools from one project to the next, but not the specific code or logic they built for you. Your NDA should make this clear.

What Happens If You Break an NDA: Possible Consequences

The same consequences apply whether you are a signatory to an NDA or the recipient of a breach. Which consequences will apply in a given situation will depend on your NDA.

Damages

  • Damages are monetary compensation for harm resulting from the breach. If the leaked information is a trade secret, the owner can sue under the federal Defend Trade Secrets Act for actual losses and unjust enrichment. The Act also allows for increased damages when the breach was committed maliciously and willfully.

Injunction

  • An injunction is a court order requiring the NDA signatory to stop using or distributing your information. This is usually the founders' priority when the leak is ongoing.

Contract Penalties

  • Many NDAs stipulate a penalty for breach, called liquidated damages. But the courts are unwilling to enforce a penalty that is punitive rather than being a reasonable approximation of losses.

Contract Termination

  • A breach of an NDA may be enough to terminate the development contract. Check the contract’s termination clause before proceeding, though. Otherwise, you might be creating another breach.

Reputational Fallout

  • Breaches of an NDA may damage your reputation with your users, investors, and other clients. If user data has been leaked, you may be subject to additional notification requirements. Consult a lawyer for advice.

Will Your NDA Hold Up?

Many startup founders assume that an NDA is automatically enforceable, as long as it’s been signed by the parties. Well, are NDAs enforceable? In many cases, they are. But the courts will look at the specifics of your NDA.

Before you jump to a lawsuit, read up on when courts actually uphold an NDA and check whether yours meets the basics, such as a clear definition of what counts as confidential and something given in exchange for signing.

The definition of confidential information should be clear. It’s better to spell out what information is covered (code, designs, roadmaps, data) than to simply say “all information.” The NDA’s scope and length should also be reasonable.

What to Do If a Developer Breaks Your NDA

If you think your NDA is being breached, here are the steps to take. Document the evidence first: take screenshots and save links. Also save a copy of the NDA and any other communications you had with your developer during the project. Don’t confront the developer.

Next, remove their access to all repositories, cloud accounts, design tools, and other channels they’ve used during the project. If your developer relationship ends badly on a Friday, you don’t want to give them a reason to leak more data.

Then, send the developer a written notice. Explain what they shared, cite the NDA, and ask them to remove the information and provide you with written confirmation.

Before you move to sue, talk to a lawyer. They can advise you on whether your NDA is enforceable and which court it should be enforced in. A lawyer can also tell you how much it will cost to move forward.

Finally, consider if you can pursue your claim as trade secret theft. If the leaked information is a valuable trade secret and is not publicly available, your lawyer can advise you on whether you can claim trade secret misappropriation. The USPTO states that in such cases, the court may award damages and legal fees as well as issue a permanent injunction.

How to Protect the Next Development Contract

Man signing a document with a pen

Photo by Jakub Żerdzicki on Unsplash

To safeguard your next development contract, follow these tips for an NDA to use with agencies, freelancers, or offshore companies.

Add a clause for the assignment of intellectual property (IP). An NDA only covers secrecy, and ownership of the code needs to be explicitly addressed in the main contract.

Provide limited access. Ensure that your development team members only have access to the repositories and accounts required. Also be sure to revoke access at the conclusion of the project.

Be specific about what information is protected. Make sure the NDA covers not only code, but also designs, data, and roadmaps.

Include a clause about returning or deleting information upon project completion, with written confirmation.

Hold the agency accountable for subcontractors. The agency is responsible for its staff and the partners that they work with.

Check for vendors offshore. Make sure that in the case of a dispute, you know where you will be heard. Also make sure to verify with a lawyer that the NDA will hold up in their jurisdiction.

Make sure you have a budget and have chosen the right vendor. Take the time to understand the cost to outsource app development and the mobile app development companies you will be working with before you sign anything.

A helpful clause to consider adding to your NDA is a short notice period, in which the vendor is required to inform you if they have learned that information has been leaked.

Key Takeaways

In most cases, violating an NDA results in a civil claim for damages and/or an injunction and not jail time. In app development and other software projects, the most common targets for IP theft are source code, designs, roadmaps, and user data.

An NDA only stands up in court when it is clear, reasonable, and properly signed. Collect evidence and limit access before notifying anyone of the breach.

The next time you sign a development contract, make sure to include IP assignment, limited access, and a clause covering the return or deletion of the information upon project completion.

To begin, review the development contract you currently have with your developer to see whether it addresses confidential information and includes an IP assignment.